U4GM MLB The Show 26 Underrated Player Tips

Spend five minutes in Diamond Dynasty and you'll see the same mistake everywhere: players blowing their whole stack on shiny overall ratings. It's tempting, sure. But if you're trying to build a nasty squad without burning through your MLB 26 stubs, the smarter move is chasing cards that feel better than their number. Swing timing, release point, pitch speed gaps, quirks, fielding animations - that stuff wins games when both players can hit.



Budget arms that don't feel budget
Corbin Burnes is the kind of starter people should be talking about more. At roughly 5,000 stubs, he gives you a pitch mix that plays in real ranked games, not just against the CPU. John Donaldson is another headache, mostly because hitters never look comfortable against him. His low-90s slider paired with a much slower forkball makes people swing like they've guessed wrong before the ball even leaves his hand. Noah Schultz still works because of the angle and size. Sandy Alcantara's Team Affinity card is also way better than an 87 should be, while Al Leiter suits players who'd rather keep hitters guessing than dot every single corner.




PlayerBest UseWhy He Works
Corbin BurnesRotation anchorDeep mix and strong movement
John DonaldsonDeception starterBig speed gaps between pitches
Kenley JansenLate inningsCutter-heavy looks are hard to square up
Pete Crow-ArmstrongCenter fieldRange saves runs every game


Relievers worth trusting late
The bullpen is where a lot of players get careless with stubs. You don't need every expensive closer on the market. Kenley Jansen can still feel like the best right-handed reliever in the game when used right, especially if you're mixing cutter locations instead of spamming one spot. From the left side, Aaron Bummer is a pain because the sinker and cutter move just enough to avoid barrels. Garrett Cleavinger and Adrian Morejon are good cheap lefties too. They won't scare anyone on the lineup screen, but they'll get ground balls when you need them.



Catchers and infielders with real in-game value
Catcher is awkward every year, and MLB The Show 26 is no different. Biz Mackey gives you the safe route. He blocks, throws, and stops the cheap stolen bases that can ruin a close game. If you want more bat, Victor Martinez and Carlos Santana are easy to like because switch-hitting always matters. Santana becomes especially useful once you start upgrading him. Around the infield, Gil Hodges has that quick two-handed swing that catches fastballs without much panic. Barry Larkin feels similar and gets ignored way too often. Rod Carew is another fun one. His swing takes a little time, but once you get it, he's constantly finding grass. Tommy Edman and Jesús Made add flexibility, which matters more than people admit.



Outfield cards that quietly win games
Pete Crow-Armstrong might be the best example of a card playing above its price. He covers so much ground in center that you start taking away hits you probably shouldn't. Tony Gwynn brings a different kind of value: contact, vision, speed, and the ability to move around the outfield. Stan Musial is a smart pick if you need a DH or bench bat and don't want to pay Ted Williams prices. Anthony Santander's switch bat and vision make him more consistent than his raw attributes suggest, while Oscar Charleston gives you speed and a smooth swing. If you're careful with MLB 26 stubs for sale, these are the cards that let you compete without feeling outgunned.